joey_big_nose Posted November 1, 2005 Posted November 1, 2005 On the other hand it is hard to see how capping salaries would be defensible. Why should they have their salaries limited when no one else does? And how is being a footballer any different from being any other skilled artist- some musicians, film stars and writers make buckets full of cash. Presumably out of fairness we would have to cap their salaries too. Indeed to make the system water tight you would have to cap everybody's salaries. That would be no less than tragic economically, mass capital flight, brain drain and curtailment in investment. Also there is the practicle question of players just moving abroad, and free market legislation. Arguably if Hill hadn't scrapped the wage limit all the players would of just buggered off to Spain or Italy. And also what would they do with all the money they saved? Give it back to the supporters? Hmm, cant see it happening. Personally I think that they do earn too much cash and are feckless with it but rather than regulating them (which is an unfair and unworkable intrusion of the state) fans should simply refuse to be held to ransom. If demand falls as the price rises then prices should fall again.
This thread is brought to you by theterracestore.com Enter code `BRFCS` at checkout for an exclusive discount!
Fife Rover Posted November 1, 2005 Posted November 1, 2005 (edited) On the other hand it is hard to see how capping salaries would be defensible. Why should they have their salaries limited when no one else does? And how is being a footballer any different from being any other skilled artist- some musicians, film stars and writers make buckets full of cash. Presumably out of fairness we would have to cap their salaries too. Indeed to make the system water tight you would have to cap everybody's salaries. That would be no less than tragic economically, mass capital flight, brain drain and curtailment in investment. Also there is the practicle question of players just moving abroad, and free market legislation. Arguably if Hill hadn't scrapped the wage limit all the players would of just buggered off to Spain or Italy. And also what would they do with all the money they saved? Give it back to the supporters? Hmm, cant see it happening. Personally I think that they do earn too much cash and are feckless with it but rather than regulating them (which is an unfair and unworkable intrusion of the state) fans should simply refuse to be held to ransom. If demand falls as the price rises then prices should fall again. 357729[/snapback] Again what you say JBN is more or less correct, with one notable exception. You have obviously not realised that there is one major sport in Britain where a wage cap for players exists and does not seem to cause any problems at all. That is Rugby League. As for the rest, as you rightly point out it is up to each individual to choose at which point his craving for the game is insufficient to overcome his feelings of being exploited and taken for a mug by the grossly overpaid and underworked players. Which is precisely the process that began as a landslide in the early 60's and has kept on going at a reduced rate ever since. Edited November 1, 2005 by Fife Rover
DamienTC Posted November 1, 2005 Posted November 1, 2005 1: Steve Bruce... 2: El Hadji Diouf (for all the above mentioned reasons) 3: Dennis Rommedahl (lousy and lazy, has the worst crosses in international football) 4: Stig Tøfting (former Bolton and HSV-player 5: Everything Soton Honorary mentions: Savage (before Rovers bought him) Crouch (for being so darn ugly )
Cheshireblue Posted November 1, 2005 Posted November 1, 2005 Again what you say JBN is more or less correct, with one notable exception. You have obviously not realised that there is one major sport in Britain where a wage cap for players exists and does not seem to cause any problems at all. That is Rugby League. 357810[/snapback] Thebig difference is that Rugy League is only played in the UK so teh players have nowhere to go. The salary cap is based on club revenues, so you would end up with different caps on each club. Fine within Rugby as even the Bradfords and Leeds of the world don't generate that much more than the Londons and Warringtons, but in football, there would be massive differences between the likes of Fulham and Real Madrid. And of course, our good friends in Brussells would also want a word.
hovis boy Posted November 1, 2005 Posted November 1, 2005 Gary Higson. And the rest of the sports team at radio lancs,for the consistant way they always focus on the negatives when covering the rovers.
roversmum Posted November 1, 2005 Posted November 1, 2005 And all the commentators who spend matches they are supposed to be commentating on gossiping about anything except the match and then suddenly realise a goal is being scored/ someone sent off/it's half time etc.........
colin Posted November 1, 2005 Posted November 1, 2005 Something to cheer up all the Diouf-haters, I count myself as one.Blow into this bag sir
ulster-rover Posted November 10, 2005 Posted November 10, 2005 1. neil lennon- scumbag 2. mark lawrenson- never gives any team credit unless there liverpool, republic of ireland or preston 3. roy keane 4. sam allardyce 5. steve cotterill
Ronin Posted November 10, 2005 Posted November 10, 2005 Thebig difference is that Rugy League is only played in the UK so teh players have nowhere to go. The salary cap is based on club revenues, so you would end up with different caps on each club. Fine within Rugby as even the Bradfords and Leeds of the world don't generate that much more than the Londons and Warringtons, but in football, there would be massive differences between the likes of Fulham and Real Madrid. And of course, our good friends in Brussells would also want a word. 357834[/snapback] If RL players want more cash they can either switch Codes to Rugby Union, as some have, Jason Robinson and Andy Farrell being two examples, or bugger off to the NRL down under. So there is some kind of choice there.
Alex Rover Posted November 10, 2005 Posted November 10, 2005 or bugger off to the NRL down under. So there is some kind of choice there. 359861[/snapback] As I understand it the Super League pays better than the Aussie equivalent but I may be wrong.
OJRovers Posted November 11, 2005 Posted November 11, 2005 Hate Players: 1) Diouf 2) Ruud Van Horseman 3) Kevin Davies 4) Barry 'soft' Ferguson 5) Lee Bowyer Other football people: 1) Steve Bruce 2) Alex Ferguson 3) David O'leary 4) David Moyse 5) Any commentators on sky who bum Chelski/Utd/Arsenal
blue/white Posted November 11, 2005 Posted November 11, 2005 How about Phillip Cornhole @ Football365? See his recent article ? waster !
Ronin Posted November 11, 2005 Posted November 11, 2005 As I understand it the Super League pays better than the Aussie equivalent but I may be wrong. 359901[/snapback] Could be why there's a few from the NRL playing over here I guess.
AussieinUk Posted November 11, 2005 Posted November 11, 2005 Could be why there's a few from the NRL playing over here I guess. 360093[/snapback] That is sole the reason. $'s (south pacific peso) Vs £'s
USABlue Posted November 12, 2005 Posted November 12, 2005 I forgot my current least loved person in football (is that better Krislu)SEPP BLATTER
James No. 7 Posted November 12, 2005 Posted November 12, 2005 (edited) How about Phillip Cornhole @ Football365? See his recent article ? waster ! 360089[/snapback] This article, you mean? I concur! Mark Hughes, meanwhile, whose Blackburn side I wanted to see relegated on aesthetic grounds, is winning ugly, out at 66-1 from 20-1 in the summer. That sums it up. He has some sort of crusade against us and has been so since I have been visiting the site since last season. Even now he will not even admit that we are winning nicely. Obviously he did not pick up on the commentators who said we were a real pleasure to watch against Charlton with our fantastic passing game. We were so full of confidence and running rings right around Charlton, making them look very poor. Edited November 12, 2005 by James No. 7
blue/white Posted November 14, 2005 Posted November 14, 2005 Well done, James... that's exactly what I was wound up about. Cheers.
Recommended Posts