Jump to content

BRFCS

BY THE FANS, FOR THE FANS
SINCE 1996
Proudly partnered with TheTerraceStore.com

[Archived] Nickos Thread


nicko

Recommended Posts

Yes please, 5 million for a player out of form and 31 years of age ( next sesaon ) represents excellent value imo. Look at what we paid for santa cruz, Bellamy and benni himself.

Even if benni was firing in goals this season we woudnt get much more than 5 million for him due to his age.

The Benjani deal is worth £7.6m in all and he's 29. Anelka is only a year and a bit younger than McCarthy and he went for £15m!!! At the back end of last season I think we could have got £10m for him after his silver boot win.

Of course age plays a part but not as much as you are saying.....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 5.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

True but your stock rises and falls in football. Don't have the figures for Benjani and Anelka but poor form not masked by only 3 Prem goals from open play doesn't help Benni. If we got £5million it would be a decent price IMO.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Benni is one of our (if not the) best players, but his head does not seem to be at Rovers anymore. I would love him to sign a new contract if that means that he will settle down and really give a 100% in every game, like in his first season. Having a motivated McCarthy up front with Santa would be fantastic...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Benjani deal is worth £7.6m in all and he's 29. Anelka is only a year and a bit younger than McCarthy and he went for £15m!!! At the back end of last season I think we could have got £10m for him after his silver boot win.

Of course age plays a part but not as much as you are saying.....

Although Benjani isn’t a good footballer than Mccarthy IMO, City have bought Benjani on the back of his best ever run of form. Benni if sold won’t fetch anything more than 5-7 million, to accompany this Benjani creates more chances than benni due to his sheer work rate, when Benni isn’t scoring he doesn’t contribute much else to he side imo.

As for your comparison with Anelka, this is Chelsea we are talking about; and they tend to pay well over the odds for players. Additionally Anelka is one the best strikers in the Prem and has established this over several seasons with different clubs.

5 Million at the end of the season is more than a fair price for benni, if Van Nistlerooy went for a smallish sum, we are not going to get much more than 5 million for a 31 year old; out of form striker.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't, usually, but this time I think Bazzasnotsogreat has summed up McCarthy quite accurately. He is 31, he isn't playing particularly well, and he isn't currently scoring. He will have to be replaced though, and even though his price will be affected by his form of late, he is a quality striker with a lot of ability.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Who has said anything about more money, though?

I take it you don't know more about Farfan?

I am guessing it's five in midfield, with Berner on the left and Bentley slightly behind Santa Cruz in a free role like last time. Reid, Tugay and Mokoena with the three other midfield spots.. I would personally like to see McCarthy up there with Santa Cruz, or maybe Roberts can run Senderos ragged.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Who has said anything about more money, though?

MCCARTHY WOULD WANT MORE MONEY - AND A LONGER CONTRACT - TO RE-SIGN.

I take it you don't know more about Farfan?

IT SEEMS HE HAS A GET-OUT CLAUSE AND IS BEING HAWKED AROUND. HE'S OK, BUT NOTHING SPECIAL. HOWEVER HE HAS PACE.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Fair enough. A longer contract was what I was thinking, not necessarily a bumper pay rise. But that's just speculation from my point of view.

Not seen Farfan for a while, but always thought he was a tricky player for PSV. We don't have that kind of winger in our squad, and he could probably play up front aswell. The chief at PSV has confirmed the clause, but refused to tell the price.. obviously. Can I ask, Nicko, do clubs know these clauses, or are they in the dark?

And do you have any idea how much he would cost? I'm a bit skeptic, our name seems to appear out of nowhere?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Fair enough. A longer contract was what I was thinking, not necessarily a bumper pay rise. But that's just speculation from my point of view.

Not seen Farfan for a while, but always thought he was a tricky player for PSV. We don't have that kind of winger in our squad, and he could probably play up front aswell. The chief at PSV has confirmed the clause, but refused to tell the price.. obviously. Can I ask, Nicko, do clubs know these clauses, or are they in the dark?

And do you have any idea how much he would cost? I'm a bit skeptic, our name seems to appear out of nowhere?

Any agent worth his salt will have told any potential buyers how much Farfan will cost...I have no idea, but I did hear it was about £10 million two seasons ago. I will presume it has dropped as his contract runs on.

I saw him against Liverpool last season and he didn't do much for me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I saw him against Liverpool last season and he didn't do much for me.

A quick check on his scoring return in the last 16 Champions League games - rather than the Dutch Sunday League - shows that he scored none this season and two the one before.

Against Liverpool - home and way - he was too small and lightweight.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Announcements

  • You can now add BlueSky, Mastodon and X accounts to your BRFCS Profile.



×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.