[Archived] The +/- Game

[RoverRich]

Seeing as our club captain is out can we have a vote for captain as well once the team is finalised?????

[James No. 7]

+ Khizanishvili

+ Vogel

- Andrews

- Derbyshire

[brfcs5359]

+ Dunn

+ Samba

- Treacy LM

- Derbyshire LM

[RoverJoexx]

Keeper Dept:

Robinson- 15

Brown---- 12

Bunn----- 9

Defence Dept:

Centerback :

Samba------- 17

Khizanishvili- 11

Midfield Dept:

Left Midfield :

Treacy----- 9

Derbyshire- 1

Center Midfield :

Dunn----- 19

Grella---- 9

Andrews- 10

Tugay---- 13

Mokoena- 3

Vogel----- 9

In : Ooijer (Cb), Santa (Fw), Olsson (Lb), Villanueva (Fw), Emerton (Rm), Simpson (Rb), Warnock (Cm)

Out : McCarthy (Fw), Reid(Cm + Rm), Mokoena (Cb), Pedersen (Lm), Roberts (Fw), Nelsen (Cb)

Update : Only 1 spot left for Cm and Cb. 20 votes to clinch a spot. 0 vote to get eliminated.

--------Santa----Villanueva

-???---Warnock--???-----Emerton

Olsson---Ooijer----???----Simpson

-----------------???

[LeChuck]

+ Robinson

+ Dunn

- Derbyshire (LM)

- Brown

[James No. 7]

+ Khizanishvili

+ Brown

- Andrews

- Bunn

[tchocky]

+ Samba

+ Robinson

- Kish

- Brown

[brfcs5359]

+ Dunn CM

+ Andrews CM

- Treacy LM

- Derbyshire LM

[CrazyIvan]

Robinson +

Andrews (CM) +

Mokoena (CM) -

Derbyshire (LM) -

[RoverJoexx]

Keeper Dept:

Robinson- 18

Brown---- 11

Bunn----- 8

Defence Dept:

Centerback :

Samba------- 18

Khizanishvili- 11

In : Ooijer (Cb), Santa (Fw), Olsson (Lb), Villanueva (Fw), Emerton (Rm), Simpson (Rb), Warnock (Cm), Dunn (Cm), Treacy (Lm)

Out : McCarthy (Fw), Reid(Cm + Rm), Mokoena (Cb), Pedersen (Lm), Roberts (Fw), Nelsen (Cb), Derbyshire (Lm)

Update : Dunn got the last Cm position, Treacy clinch the Lm position due to no contest. Only left 1 Gk and Cb position to go.

20 votes to clinch a spot. 0 vote to get eliminated.

(??) ?? - Number of votes won

---------Santa(20)-----Villanueva(20)

Treacy(8)--Warnock(20)--Dunn(20)--Emerton(11)

Olsson(20)--Ooijer(20)----???----Simpson(15)

-------------------------???

Subs : Gk, Def, Def, Tugay(13), Andrews(11), Derbyshire(16), Fowler(3)

[RoverRich]

+ Robinson

+ Samba

- Brown

- Khizanishvili

[Al]

Robinson +

Kiz +

Samba -

Brown -

[RoverJoexx]

Defence Dept:

Centerback :

Samba------- 18

Khizanishvili- 11

In : Ooijer (Cb), Santa (Fw), Olsson (Lb), Villanueva (Fw), Emerton (Rm), Simpson (Rb), Warnock (Cm), Dunn (Cm), Treacy (Lm), Robinson (Gk)

Out : McCarthy (Fw), Reid(Cm + Rm), Mokoena (Cb), Pedersen (Lm), Roberts (Fw), Nelsen (Cb), Derbyshire (Lm)

Update : Robinson clinch keeper position, left 1 Cb position to go with Samba at driving seat atm.

20 votes to clinch a spot. 0 vote to get eliminated.

(??) ?? - Number of votes won

---------Santa(20)-----Villanueva(20)

Treacy(8)--Warnock(20)--Dunn(20)--Emerton(11)

Olsson(20)--Ooijer(20)----???----Simpson(15)

----------------------Robinson(20)

Subs : Brown(9), Def, Def, Tugay(13), Andrews(11), Derbyshire(16), Fowler(3)

[CrazyIvan]

Samba +

Khizanishvilli -

[Al]

Samba -

Khiz +

[LeChuck]

Haha, you're determined aren't you Al? Well, nothing personal but...

+ Samba

- Zurab

I just believe Samba could flourish alongside the steady presence of Ooijer, I think he would be far better for his development than the erratic Nelsen we've seen for the past 12-18 months.

[RoverRich]

Al you have already voted once today so technically your second vote should not be counted and Samba should have gained the last spot but just to make sure he does:

+ Samba

- Khizanishvili

[brfcs5359]

+ Samba

- Kish

+ Robinson

- Brown

[brfcs5359]

In : Ooijer (Cb), Santa (Fw), Olsson (Lb), Villanueva (Fw), Emerton (Rm), Simpson (Rb), Warnock (Cm), Dunn (Cm), Treacy (Lm), Robinson (Gk)

Out : McCarthy (Fw), Reid(Cm + Rm), Mokoena (Cb), Pedersen (Lm), Roberts (Fw), Nelsen (Cb), Derbyshire (Lm)

Update : Robinson clinch keeper position, left 1 Cb position to go with Samba at driving seat atm.

20 votes to clinch a spot. 0 vote to get eliminated.

(??) ?? - Number of votes won

---------Santa(20)-----Villanueva(20)

Treacy(8)--Warnock(20)--Dunn(20)--Emerton(11)

Olsson(20)--Ooijer(20)----???----Simpson(15)

----------------------Robinson(20)

Subs : Brown(9), Def, Def, Tugay(13), Andrews(11), Derbyshire(16), Fowler(3)

Out : McCarthy (Fw), Reid(Cm + Rm), Mokoena (Cb), Pedersen (Lm), Roberts (Fw), Nelsen (Cb), Derbyshire (Lm)

Thats pretty much how I see us in the January transfer window. We have two or three youngsters coming through and a bigger than we have had squad. So in order to buy we should sell at top dollar(ish) providing we can get it. If 4 of these moved on I think we have done well and give us room to replace;

£5m McCarthy (Fw)

£3m Reid (Cm + Rm),

£1.5mMokoena (Cb),

£4m Pedersen (Lm),

£3m Roberts (Fw),

£3m Nelsen (Cb),

£2m Derbyshire (Lm)

£500k Treacy

£500k Vogel

RELEASED Fowler

[RoverJoexx]

In : Ooijer (Cb), Santa (Fw), Olsson (Lb), Villanueva (Fw), Emerton (Rm), Simpson (Rb), Warnock (Cm), Dunn (Cm), Treacy (Lm), Robinson (Gk),Samba (Cb)

Out : McCarthy (Fw), Reid(Cm + Rm), Mokoena (Cb), Pedersen (Lm), Roberts (Fw), Nelsen (Cb), Derbyshire (Lm)

Update : With Samba taking the last Cb position, I concluded the end of this game and thanks for all who contributed to this thread.

Here our game's 442 lineup up, one we would like them to excel at their respective position for us this season.

Note : (??) - Number of votes won

------------Santa(20)----Villanueva(20)

Treacy(8)--Warnock(20)--Dunn(20)--Emerton(11)

Olsson(20)--Ooijer(20)--Samba(20)---Simpson(15)

----------------------Robinson(20)

Subs : Brown(9), Khizanishvili(9), Nelsen(0), Tugay(13), Andrews(11), Derbyshire(16), Fowler(3)

[RoverJoexx]

Base on the progression of this game. I think a 433 formation will reflect better from the votes that's being made for each player.

Because of 1) a lack of qualities at left midfield from our fans view and 2) Emerton was once leading our Cm position but got draft to Rm due to no contest there.

So the 433 formation look like this;

---Villanueva(20)--Santa(20)--Derbyshire(16)

------Warnock(20)--Dunn(20)--Emerton(18)

Olsson(20)--Ooijer(20)--Samba(20)--Simpson(15)

----------------------Robinson(20)

Subs : Brown(9), Khizanishvili(9), Tugay(13), Andrews(11), Grella(9), Treacy(8), Fowler(3)

[LeChuck]

I think the 4-4-2 version looks better than that...I wouldn't have picked Dunn for that role if I knew the line-up was heading in that direction, he's hardly a holding midfielder.

[T4E]

------------Santa(20)----Villanueva(20)

Treacy(8)--Warnock(20)--Dunn(20)--Emerton(11)

Olsson(20)--Ooijer(20)--Samba(20)---Simpson(15)

----------------------Robinson(20)

Subs : Brown(9), Khizanishvili(9), Nelsen(0), Tugay(13), Andrews(11), Derbyshire(16), Fowler(3)

Interesting how this turned out - our "choice" of right midfielder ended up making the team despite only ending up with 1 more vote than he actually started the game with. Speaks volumes for our issues in that position.