Jump to content

BRFCS

BY THE FANS, FOR THE FANS, SINCE 1996
Proudly partnered with TheTerraceStore.com

[Archived] Givet a rest?

Stuart

By Stuart
in Football Messageboard Archive

Recommended Posts

Stuart World Cup

Stuart

Posted
Posted

The facts are he's had his share of injury; he missed the last few games through suspension; and has an on-going contractual dispute with the club.

Yet he's a professional footballer; paid a small fortune, regardless of tax debates; is a key player in our defence; and we were led to believe, by Kean, this week, that he'll be putting his off-field issues to one side.

So where the hell was he yesterday (not even on the bench), when will he return, and why is there no club statement?

47er

47er

Posted
Posted

The facts are he's had his share of injury; he missed the last few games through suspension; and has an on-going contractual dispute with the club.

Yet he's a professional footballer; paid a small fortune, regardless of tax debates; is a key player in our defence; and we were led to believe, by Kean, this week, that he'll be putting his off-field issues to one side.

So where the hell was he yesterday (not even on the bench), when will he return, and why is there no club statement?

Here's a statement of sorts.Doesn't tell us what we want to know though. Why wasn't he left-back so that Ollson could attack them?

BRFC95 Premier League

BRFC95

Posted
Posted

He "was not in the right frame of mind" ... Wouldn't be surprised if he never plays for us again and it sold in the summer

I wouldn't be surprised if Kean has been told not to pick him

Stuart World Cup

Stuart

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Makes you wonder about his cashflow situation is this alleged tax bill is causing him so much concern.

Shame, as the one thing you used to be able to say about mercernary footballers is that they were at least professional.

Not suggesting Givet is a mercenary, btw, but if he is refusing to play because of it, he needs to go as he'd be bad for morale.

Even greater shame is that he is one of our four musketeers in defence, and it would mean we could release Olsson to the wing and keep Peds as sub (in case of dire emergencies).

braddock Champions League

braddock

Posted
Posted

People 'not being surprised' if any number of hypothesises have happened doesn't actually mean anything concrete, especially when their is no evidence behind it.

LeChuck World Cup

LeChuck

Posted
Posted

I think I'm in a minority of one who thinks Olsson is better than him at full back. Givet gets done for pace on a regular basis and offers nothing going forward, meaning opposition wingers don't have to worry about defending.

Admittedly being short of wingers means we need to clone Olsson. I'd be quite happy to see the back of Givet this summer though.

toogs Premier League

toogs

Posted
Posted

I think I'm in a minority of one who thinks Olsson is better than him at full back. Givet gets done for pace on a regular basis and offers nothing going forward, meaning opposition wingers don't have to worry about defending.

Admittedly being short of wingers means we need to clone Olsson. I'd be quite happy to see the back of Givet this summer though.

Will his twin do? ;)

Stuart World Cup

Stuart

Posted
  • Author
Posted

I think I'm in a minority of one who thinks Olsson is better than him at full back. Givet gets done for pace on a regular basis and offers nothing going forward, meaning opposition wingers don't have to worry about defending.

Admittedly being short of wingers means we need to clone Olsson. I'd be quite happy to see the back of Givet this summer though.

I don't think it's so much that LeChuck. Most people seem to agree that Olsson is a much greater asset to team when he's played on the wing.

Givet is not a full back by any stretch but he's about our only option. Although maybe it's time to think about "converting" Pedersen...

den

den

Posted
Posted

I think I'm in a minority of one who thinks Olsson is better than him at full back. Givet gets done for pace on a regular basis and offers nothing going forward, meaning opposition wingers don't have to worry about defending.

Admittedly being short of wingers means we need to clone Olsson. I'd be quite happy to see the back of Givet this summer though.

Givet has the advantage of experience over Olssen, LeChuck. At times, and especially in defence, that's invaluable. Givet isn't great for sure. He is slow for a full back and his passing can be quite ordinary to say the least. The advantage experience gives him, is that he gets the decision making right more often than not. Olssen's problems at full back seem to be his lack of concentration resulting in him getting caught out of position, coupled with trying to be a bit too clever some times. That was highlighted at Wigan earlier this season when he tried to play his way out of a tight spot, rather than booting it into the top tier. It cost us a goal and resulted in Samba giving him a roasting.

Parsonblue

Parsonblue

Posted
Posted

Interesting to note that Givet has only featured once since we started on this terrible run of results - the game at Fulham. Personally, I believe we miss his experience and tackling ability at the back. Having Givet in the team allows Olsson to play wide on the left and his ability to play in the centre of defence gives the manager greater options when making substitions. On Friday Kean talked about Givet as though he was a certain starter and then on Saturday we get guff about his head not being right.

If Givet is refusing to play I assume we have stopped his wages. If he isn't refusing to play then he should be in the team. Either way it's up to Kean and Mrs. Desai to sort it out for the good of the club.

92er Champions League

92er

Posted
Posted

Interesting to note that Givet has only featured once since we started on this terrible run of results - the game at Fulham. Personally, I believe we miss his experience and tackling ability at the back. Having Givet in the team allows Olsson to play wide on the left and his ability to play in the centre of defence gives the manager greater options when making substitions.

I think both players have made a number of defensive mistakes this season.What I like about Givet at full back is it gives Olsson the chance to really have a go at their right back.

den

den

Posted
Posted

Either way it's up to Kean and Mrs. Desai to sort it out for the good of the club.

I've thought about these situations myself Parsonblue. Who is there that Kean can turn to, to help sort these kind of problems out - when JW is gone. No-one is there?

Parsonblue

Parsonblue

Posted
Posted

I've thought about these situations myself Parsonblue. Who is there that Kean can turn to, to help sort these kind of problems out - when JW is gone. No-one is there?

That is the problem. A novice manager and no chairman. I suspect that there is now nobody at Ewood with the power to make any decisions. From what I hear Mrs. Desai has the final word on all decisions relating to their various business and I believe that her word is final. That may be OK for the businesses that they run in India, but trying to run a football club on the other side of the world, where decisions need to be taken instantly as circumstances dictate, is another matter. The management structure off the field is just as confused as the management team looking after playing affairs.

roverwhelmed Premier League

roverwhelmed

Posted
Posted

That is the problem. A novice manager and no chairman. I suspect that there is now nobody at Ewood with the power to make any decisions. From what I hear Mrs. Desai has the final word on all decisions relating to their various business and I believe that her word is final. That may be OK for the businesses that they run in India, but trying to run a football club on the other side of the world, where decisions need to be taken instantly as circumstances dictate, is another matter. The management structure off the field is just as confused as the management team looking after playing affairs.

:wacko: Depressing.

I hope she makes a hasty final decision to sell up.

Majiball World Cup

Majiball

Posted
Posted

All the people heaping this on kean/Venky's were proven wrong by the fact that this dispute has been going on since before they arrived, it is a contractual disagreement, a contract which JW/BS/GG signed, not Kean or anyone else.

I could consequently argue that Givet never felt unfit to play under Sam???

booth World Cup

booth

Posted
Posted

All the people heaping this on kean/Venky's were proven wrong by the fact that this dispute has been going on since before they arrived, it is a contractual disagreement, a contract which JW/BS/GG signed, not Kean or anyone else.

It seems someone is at fault for Givet not recently playing though as he's been playing happily enough for several months with the dispute ongoing. Then he's dropped, and according to Kean his head isn't right.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing


×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.