Let's Talk Tyrhys Dolan

[BlackburnEnd75]

14 hours ago, Tyrone Shoelaces said:

I don’t know what Hedges brings to the party. Most of the time you don’t know he’s playing.

One of our many strange signings. We paid a fee when we could have had him for nothing a few months later.

I think he is good defensively in that he works hard and protects his full back.

Interesting that eustace has admitted he was going to start ACD before his knock and he thought Hedges was  very good on Saturday  or something to that effect

[roversfan99]

24 minutes ago, BlackburnEnd75 said:

I think he is good defensively in that he works hard and protects his full back.

Interesting that eustace has admitted he was going to start ACD before his knock and he thought Hedges was  very good on Saturday  or something to that effect

Where did he mention about ACD?

[chaddyrovers]

32 minutes ago, roversfan99 said:

Where did he mention about ACD?

In his comments with LT about ACD and McFadzean injuries

[M_B]

12 hours ago, Admiral Nelsen said:

 

Yes, pretty productive. Wouldn't go any further than that, but 13 goals/assists since the start of last season (which he missed a decent chunk of through injury) is decent. Not brilliant, but if we had another one or two with those sorts of contributions then we wouldn't have relied on Szmodics as much as we did.

And I think his decision making is miles better too. When he first arrived he was a bundle of energy who would run at players, but his final ball was like rolling a dice and he'd regularly run himself into blind alleys. Now he takes fewer touches and when he gets the ball in the right areas (not often enough) looks to pick a pass more. You could never see him providing the sort of assist like did at Leeds away a few years ago, for instance. I'm not saying he's a world beater and he'll always be up against it being as small as he is, but I think he's developing pretty well all things considered. 

Definitely agree with your second point. It seems like we've had rocks or diamonds up front for a long while. Or in Brereton's case, rocks that turn into diamonds!

He was playing really well last season, our form fell off a cliff with his injury.

He's had a good season up to now apart from the 3 away games when the team, as a whole, struggled.

[47er]

Another player who won't sign enjoying his time at Ewood. Loves the manager etc etc

https://www.lancashiretelegraph.co.uk/sport/24764488.blackburn-rovers-eustace-put-belief-me-says-dolan/

[Leonard Venkhater]

2 hours ago, 47er said:

Another player who won't sign enjoying his time at Ewood. Loves the manager etc etc

https://www.lancashiretelegraph.co.uk/sport/24764488.blackburn-rovers-eustace-put-belief-me-says-dolan/

I didn't quite buy it, when I read the piece.

[philipl]

Given the abuse Dolan has received, why would have any loyalty to the fans?

The renewal negotiations will be purely transactional and unless we are in the Prem, he is going.

[K-Hod]

1 hour ago, philipl said:

Given the abuse Dolan has received, why would have any loyalty to the fans?

The renewal negotiations will be purely transactional and unless we are in the Prem, he is going.

What abuse? Or do you mean criticism that's being re-defined as abuse to suit an argument?

[Mattyblue]

Never received any abuse, fans have been great with him, just like they were when BB was terrible for years, just like they are being with Gueye who is without doubt one of the worst strikers I’ve seen in a blue and white shirt on current form. TD has put a shift in and some good performances throughout, so why would he be ‘abused’?

Supportive, patient fans here.

[Upside Down]

21 minutes ago, Mattyblue said:

Never received any abuse, fans have been great with him, just like they were when BB was terrible for years, just like they are being with Gueye who is without doubt one of the worst strikers I’ve seen in a blue and white shirt on current form. TD has put a shift in and some good performances throughout, so why would he be ‘abused’?

Supportive, patient fans here.

Probably one of the most patient fanbases you'll find.

Try playing like that for one of the north east clubs.

[47er]

4 hours ago, philipl said:

Given the abuse Dolan has received, why would have any loyalty to the fans?

The renewal negotiations will be purely transactional and unless we are in the Prem, he is going.

I like Dolan. I think most Rovers fans do. He's not Premiership standard but I'd imagine a few Championship sides would happily take him on for no transfer fee.

Blackburn Rovers----the gift that keeps on giving.

Edited December 6, 2024 by 47er

[Dreams of 1995]

I just don't think Dolan is good enough for the Championship tbh

The days he shows up are too few and far between. That inconsistency puts him a league or two below

Quite often he can misplace passes, run into danger and have such a baggy touch that the whole attack breaks down. He isn't a number 10. He isn't a striker. He isn't a winger. So I struggle to find a place for him. In the long-term we will need to find better

[roversfan99]

Abuse only heard from Malta.

[Upside Down]

37 minutes ago, Dreams of 1995 said:

I just don't think Dolan is good enough for the Championship tbh

The days he shows up are too few and far between. That inconsistency puts him a league or two below

Quite often he can misplace passes, run into danger and have such a baggy touch that the whole attack breaks down. He isn't a number 10. He isn't a striker. He isn't a winger. So I struggle to find a place for him. In the long-term we will need to find better

TBF you can say that about a lot of players in this league, that's why they're in this league and not the one above.

[Mattyblue]

He’s a middling Championship player and he’ll be at a middling Championship club next season.

[Tyrone Shoelaces]

50 minutes ago, Dreams of 1995 said:

I just don't think Dolan is good enough for the Championship tbh

The days he shows up are too few and far between. That inconsistency puts him a league or two below

Quite often he can misplace passes, run into danger and have such a baggy touch that the whole attack breaks down. He isn't a number 10. He isn't a striker. He isn't a winger. So I struggle to find a place for him. In the long-term we will need to find better

There’s a player in there but unless he can dramatically improve his game management skills he’ll never reach his potential. His decision making is pretty poor. He gets as many decisions wrong as he gets right.

[TheRevAshton]

Good player on his day, however his good performances are very few and far between.

He's still young and has time to find some consistency... though even if he did I doubt he'd ever be above Championship level.

Not sure on the ins-and-outs of his contract situation, could well be the case that he's getting low-balled... but I was annoyed after reading in Elliott Jackson's article yesterday that "The current expectation is that Dolan will assess his options in the summer and leave on a free transfer".

What is the kid expecting? He has 1 good game for every 4 that he's awful... he needs to remember how Rovers gave him a lifeline when he was binned off by Preston.

I think he will indeed leave on a free, and like many before him, Dolan will see that the grass isn't always greener.

[rigger]

7 hours ago, philipl said:

Given the abuse Dolan has received, why would have any loyalty to the fans?

The renewal negotiations will be purely transactional and unless we are in the Prem, he is going.

Is it abuse, when it is true ?

[roversfan99]

3 hours ago, TheRevAshton said:

Good player on his day, however his good performances are very few and far between.

He's still young and has time to find some consistency... though even if he did I doubt he'd ever be above Championship level.

Not sure on the ins-and-outs of his contract situation, could well be the case that he's getting low-balled... but I was annoyed after reading in Elliott Jackson's article yesterday that "The current expectation is that Dolan will assess his options in the summer and leave on a free transfer".

What is the kid expecting? He has 1 good game for every 4 that he's awful... he needs to remember how Rovers gave him a lifeline when he was binned off by Preston.

I think he will indeed leave on a free, and like many before him, Dolan will see that the grass isn't always greener.

In general, I dont think the narrative that the grass isnt greener for many really applies anymore. It usually is, even if that involves spells of Premier League football followed by loans to play regular top end Championship football.

With Dolan though, I dont think he necessarily will go onto bigger and better things. I dont think he should feel an obligation of loyalty though.

Edited December 6, 2024 by roversfan99

[speeeeeeedie]

I'm with everybody bar Phil. He doesn't get "abuse", he gets pulled up for his inconsistent erratic play. As has been pointed out, he's not an out and out striker, a winger, or a second striker. He works hard but his decision making is sub-par. His finishing is mediocre, and he dwells on the ball for too long. He certainly isn't a Premier League standard player.

Every game I watch Rovers on TV over here it has some bog standard commentator doing the game, with no 2nd "expert" helping. It doesn't matter who it is (they all sound the same to me) they all get excited mentioning Dolan's name like he's Rovers best player. Maybe it's because he runs around a lot? 

[M_B]

6 hours ago, speeeeeeedie said:

I'm with everybody bar Phil. He doesn't get "abuse", he gets pulled up for his inconsistent erratic play. As has been pointed out, he's not an out and out striker, a winger, or a second striker. He works hard but his decision making is sub-par. His finishing is mediocre, and he dwells on the ball for too long. He certainly isn't a Premier League standard player.

Every game I watch Rovers on TV over here it has some bog standard commentator doing the game, with no 2nd "expert" helping. It doesn't matter who it is (they all sound the same to me) they all get excited mentioning Dolan's name like he's Rovers best player. Maybe it's because he runs around a lot? 

And yet he was rightly named man of the match on Saturday. Doesn't sound like the player you described.

[rigger]

56 minutes ago, M_B said:

And yet he was rightly named man of the match on Saturday. Doesn't sound like the player you described.

The problem is that Dolan might be, the discribed player for the next few matches.

[SIMON GARNERS 194]

A player who Blows hot 'n' Cold needs to be realistic with his demands.

[M_B]

7 minutes ago, rigger said:

The problem is that Dolan might be, the discribed player for the next few matches.

I wouldn't say next few, he isn't that inconsistent, but he's always likely to throw in a stinker, but who isn't?

The thing with Dolan is that when we do lose, or sometimes even draw, he can receive an unrealistic amount of stick for an overall poor team performance.

 

[RevidgeBlue]

Some very unfair comments about Dolan on here I think. Is he absolutely top drawer? No, but I'd nevertheless have him pegged as one of our slightly better players and is the ideal age for a player you'd want to keep at the Club.

It's difficult to have a worthwhile opinion on this without knowing what the Club are offering and what he's asking for. I can't remember if he's had a new deal since originally signing but if not he'll currently be on relative peanuts for a Championship player  who regularly starts.

From the players' point of view, he's probably at the wrong Club at the wrong time caught in the middle of Venky's/Waggott/Pasha inspired austerity and belt tightening. My expectation is he'll be the latest in a succession of players to leave for nothing and he'll end up at another Championship Club on considerably more money. On balance they'll probably be better for it as well.

From our point of view the key question should be not the wages per se but can we replace him with better? I'd venture to suggest the answer will be "no" and he'll be replaced with another cheap journeyman approaching the end of his career who was never any good to start with like Hedges.