Makhtar Gueye

[Leonard Venkhater]

On 07/11/2024 at 16:02, martonrover said:

🎶 Makhtar Gueye, you should’ve stayed at home yesterday.

Ah-ha, just can’t describe, the feeling when that header went wide 🎶 (ok, it went over, but that doesn’t rhyme as well).

With apologies to Andy McCluskey.

No apologies necessary. Made me laugh out loud!

[AllRoverAsia]

2 hours ago, Tyrone Shoelaces said:

That’s a goal. 

100%

A bent referee.

[lraC]

7 hours ago, Roverthechimp said:

Jack Vale or Gueye?

I know which one I have seen contribute more to the team but we desperately need Chile to give him a call unless Leonard steps up or we sign someone else come January (or the summer if we are close enough to 50 points by January)

Send him some Chile Con Carne, that might do the trick. 

[bluebruce]

10 hours ago, roversfan99 said:

The thing with Brown is in his day, he was a competent Championship striker. He turned up here with his knees knackered and he spent most of his time injured. Gueye is coming into his supposed prime.

Was he?

His best ever Championship season was a small sample 5 goals in 17 games for PNE. Apart from that, his best season was the one before he joined us, where he got 9 in 40 for Doncaster in this league. So unless he got his knees knackered pretty much right at the end of that season, the suggestion he was finished makes no sense, he was basically at his peak.

All his other seasons in this league, he never scored more than 6, which he did twice, in 30 games and in 43 games. Those are 1 in 5 and less than 1 in 7.16 ratios respectively. For a striker. And those were some of his best ever seasons. He spent most of his career in the Championship, and scored 5 or more goals in just 5 seasons. All the others he scored 3 or less. So I think the claim he was a competent Championship striker is also generous. If he played up top here with those numbers, we'd have said he was shit, get rid.

[Mike E]

I remember someone describing him as ‘like having Samba up front’. I think that description is spot on tbh.

Edited December 11 by Mike E

[joey_big_nose]

Great he got the goal yesterday, seems such a likeable guy. Still think his performance was well below what we saw up until the Burnley sending off. But hopefully now with his confidence up he can go back to his early form!

[Groundhog]

His goal reminded me of some of Sutton's goals for us, especially our 2nd goal at West Ham away in the cup in the 90s - grit, strength and determination to force himself past the defender - only one player winning that ball.

No one else in the team is scoring goals like that, and what I like about us this season is we're scoring all sorts of goals, rather than previous seasons where we just saw repeats of Diaz or Szmodics cutting in from the left on a breakaway. 

 

[Tyrone Shoelaces]

It was a bit Kevin Moran at Derby.

[riverholmes]

One of Gueye’s issues might be positioning. When the cross first went in, he was moving away from the goal, as if he didn’t fancy competing with the defenders. When it came in again, from JRC (nice control from him), Gueye wasn’t really on the move much - but his strength and height seemed to win the day. 

[Mattyblue]

10 hours ago, Groundhog said:

His goal reminded me of some of Sutton's goals for us, especially our 2nd goal at West Ham away in the cup in the 90s - grit, strength and determination to force himself past the defender - only one player winning that ball.

No one else in the team is scoring goals like that, and what I like about us this season is we're scoring all sorts of goals, rather than previous seasons where we just saw repeats of Diaz or Szmodics cutting in from the left on a breakaway. 

 

What always amuses me about 90s clips is that away fans always obediently sat down in these new fangled seated away ends… not quite the case now 😅

[bluebruce]

20 hours ago, riverholmes said:

One of Gueye’s issues might be positioning. When the cross first went in, he was moving away from the goal, as if he didn’t fancy competing with the defenders. When it came in again, from JRC (nice control from him), Gueye wasn’t really on the move much - but his strength and height seemed to win the day. 

For all his flaws, Gueye doesn't remotely strike me as someone who is afraid to mix it with defenders. I expect he was trying to peel off the defender, which is a common and often effective tactic.

[47er]

I've been talking about Gueye in terms of "he's a lot to learn but he can be coached".

When I got round to looking at his age I was astonished to find he is 27!!

Surely at that age he ought to be the finished article ( in which case someone else would have bought him!)

Not as optimistic about his future now. We really are are on the breadline aren't we?

 

[SIMON GARNERS 194]

Need a lot more from this fella to change my mind.

[Exiled_Rover]

On 12/12/2024 at 21:00, 47er said:

I've been talking about Gueye in terms of "he's a lot to learn but he can be coached".

When I got round to looking at his age I was astonished to find he is 27!!

Surely at that age he ought to be the finished article ( in which case someone else would have bought him!)

Not as optimistic about his future now. We really are are on the breadline aren't we?

 

Everyone was told exactly what he was when we bought him - a big, athletic, disruptive CF (one who wins headers, holds the ball up and brings others into play) that can't finish. 

That's exactly what we've seen from him.

[Tyrone Shoelaces]

7 hours ago, Exiled_Rover said:

Everyone was told exactly what he was when we bought him - a big, athletic, disruptive CF (one who wins headers, holds the ball up and brings others into play) that can't finish. 

That's exactly what we've seen from him.

If you can’t put chances like the one today away what can you score from ?

[simongarnerisgod]

big mak looked like he belonged at this level today,despite the amazing non finish,i still adhere to the fact he offers far more than gallagher

yuki finding out that english football is`nt the polite kickabout that it is in japan,he`s taken a lot of fouls this season but worked his arris off as usual

[wilsdenrover]

21 minutes ago, simongarnerisgod said:

big mak looked like he belonged at this level today,despite the amazing non finish,i still adhere to the fact he offers far more than gallagher

yuki finding out that english football is`nt the polite kickabout that it is in japan,he`s taken a lot of fouls this season but worked his arris off as usual

The Japanese are polite but they’re certainly not soft.

(Massive generalisation alert!!)

[simongarnerisgod]

12 minutes ago, wilsdenrover said:

The Japanese are polite but they’re certainly not soft.

(Massive generalisation alert!!)

i was refering to japanese football not it`s citizens

[wilsdenrover]

8 minutes ago, simongarnerisgod said:

i was refering to japanese football not it`s citizens

I know you were 😀

Just in case it wasn’t clear, the massive generalisation was mine not yours.

[DE.]

1 hour ago, simongarnerisgod said:

big mak looked like he belonged at this level today,despite the amazing non finish

I think you mean his sublime combo dummy-backheel assist 😎 

[roverblue]

Great performance today dominated the Luton defenders and won practically everything he went in for. Did some good defensive clearances as well. Good to see something from him and let’s hope it continues like this 

[Bohinen1983]

To think people called, and still do, Jason Roberts a donkey..  Gueye is such a likeable guy.  Has some great attributes, I do hope it clicks for him..  He seems pretty decent running with the ball which suprises me a lot..

I think there's a lot to be said for character. The lad appears to actually be proud to wear the shirt. He's aggressive, wants to win, has a relationship with the fans. I love him.  A welcome, addition.  We've had much worse.  We've had better. For me, seeing someone wear the shirt that wants, and is proud to wear it is brilliant. 

[Herbie6590]

We won well yesterday & Beck got him out of jail but let’s be honest, Sam Gallagher misses that & we’d all be up in arms. If Rovers are genuinely serious about promotion Gueye needs to be no more than a last 10 minute impact sub. We are crying out for a Danny Graham type player.

[47er]

1 hour ago, Herbie6590 said:

We won well yesterday & Beck got him out of jail but let’s be honest, Sam Gallagher misses that & we’d all be up in arms. If Rovers are genuinely serious about promotion Gueye needs to be no more than a last 10 minute impact sub. We are crying out for a Danny Graham type player.

Are we really crediting Gueye with an assist for Beck's goal or is it a joke?

[DE.]

4 minutes ago, 47er said:

Are we really crediting Gueye with an assist for Beck's goal or is it a joke?

BBC credited him with the assist.