European Court rules FIFA transfer fees illegal

[waynerovers]

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/articles/cjwdydnl3w0o

 

If they were to go ahead with this I can see a lot of smaller clubs going out of business as they rely on transfer fees for running costs. very bad news for football.

[wilsdenrover]

11 minutes ago, waynerovers said:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/articles/cjwdydnl3w0o

 

If they were to go ahead with this I can see a lot of smaller clubs going out of business as they rely on transfer fees for running costs. very bad news for football.

I can’t see anything that suggests transfer fees have been ruled illegal in that article.

It looks to me like a ‘niche’ ruling that the press will speculate into something far bigger than it is.

 

 

[KentExile]

12 minutes ago, wilsdenrover said:

I can’t see anything that suggests transfer fees have been ruled illegal in that article.

It looks to me like a ‘niche’ ruling that the press will speculate into something far bigger than it is.

 

 

If I am not misreading things, it looks to me that from now on, if a club terminates a contract of a player, they cannot then try to ask for compensation (a transfer fee) if/when the player in question finds a new club.  Which seems logical.  

If the above is correct then the issue is if a player fancies getting a move, he could potentially try to get himself sacked (not turning up to training/games, or doing a Duffy etc) so he can move on a free and pocket some or all of the the "dodged transfer fee" as a signing on bonus.

It may also impact transfer window rules for players who have their contracts terminated whilst a window is closed (due to freedom of movement issues)

Edited October 4, 2024 by KentExile

[wilsdenrover]

1 hour ago, KentExile said:

If I am not misreading things, it looks to me that from now on, if a club terminates a contract of a player, they cannot then try to ask for compensation (a transfer fee) if/when the player in question finds a new club.  Which seems logical.  

If the above is correct then the issue is if a player fancies getting a move, he could potentially try to get himself sacked (not turning up to training/games, or doing a Duffy etc) so he can move on a free and pocket some or all of the the "dodged transfer fee" as a signing on bonus.

It may also impact transfer window rules for players who have their contracts terminated whilst a window is closed (due to freedom of movement issues)

If he is sacked for breach of contract (which your examples would be) wouldn’t the loss of transfer fee be a consequential loss for which the club could sue the player?
 

 

[Herbie6590]

1 minute ago, wilsdenrover said:

If he is sacked for breach of contract (which your examples would be) wouldn’t the loss of transfer fee be a consequential loss for which the club could sue the player?
 

 

That’s how this case ended up in court…

[wilsdenrover]

1 minute ago, Herbie6590 said:

That’s how this case ended up in court…

Unless I’m mistaken (which is often the case 😁😁) the court hasn’t said Diarra didn’t breach his contract but that this shouldn’t be used to prevent him from working elsewhere.

[Herbie6590]

1 minute ago, wilsdenrover said:

Unless I’m mistaken (which is often the case 😁😁) the court hasn’t said Diarra didn’t breach his contract but that this shouldn’t be used to prevent him from working elsewhere.

Yes, but it was the attempt by the club to get compensation from the player that started the whole thing…

I suspect where this will end up will be pre-ordained compensation payments to leave a contract early & the player secures a signing on fee from the new club to cover the compensation paid…possibly…🤷‍♂️😆

[wilsdenrover]

4 minutes ago, Herbie6590 said:

Yes, but it was the attempt by the club to get compensation from the player that started the whole thing…

I suspect where this will end up will be pre-ordained compensation payments to leave a contract early & the player secures a signing on fee from the new club to cover the compensation paid…possibly…🤷‍♂️😆

The lower this contracted figure was the lower the player’s wages would be right??😁