FA Cup - season 2024-25

[chaddyrovers]

37 minutes ago, DavidMailsTightPerm said:

Good chance of being on TV as well

I reckon Man City game at Leyton Orient or Derby, Liverpool game at Plymouth, Newcastle game at Birmingham, Villa vs Spurs, Exeter vs Forest will be TV games. 

Edited Sunday at 19:38 by chaddyrovers

[martonrover]

Just now, simongarnerisgod said:

or the equally bad thursday night😒

Agreed, although they said the matches will be played between 7th (Friday), and 10th (Monday), so maybe that was a one - off for the third round?

[wilsdenrover]

3 minutes ago, chaddyrovers said:

I reckon Man City game at Leyton orient, Liverpool game at Plymouth, Newcastle game at Birmingham, Villa vs Spurs, Exeter vs Forest will be TV games. 

I’d be amazed if they don’t pick Van Nistelrooy’s return to Old Trafford. 
 

They might even mention it involves Leicester.

[Upside Down]

With no replays I think that's the end of proper cup upsets. Sure, we'll get a league one side beating a championship side etc but we're not going to see none league outfits knocking out a top division side ever again.

There's no way the lower division teams can compete with the fitness, strength, quality and depth of the higher level.

Complete joke. Oh well, at least we get more turgid early round European games where Man City and Real Madrid can plod on for 90 minutes as they just go through the motions.

 

[Mattyblue]

No chance Man Utd won’t be picked. Doesn’t matter if it’s Arsenal away or Barnet at home, if they’re in the cup, they’re on TV.

All about the ratings as millions of pathetic armchair glory hunters will be tuning in.

[danger19_80]

9 minutes ago, chaddyrovers said:

I reckon Man City game at Leyton orient

Leyton Orient will have to beat Derby first

[BRFC4EVA]

Reasonable draw for us. Home game against poor prem opposition and the away team will sell out the Darwen end.

However this is not the main take home from this round. This is the first time since the disgraceful, gravy train, elitist decision to remove replays, that a really low down team has been affected vs prem opposition.

Tamworth should be looking forward to a money spinning exciting opportunity to play at Spurs new magnificent ground. Instead they're knackered, having to play an extra 30 mins and out the competition. That money could have set them up for the next 5 years.

The irony shouldn't be lost that it is against Spurs, who played that ridiculous friendly on the other side of the planet 3 days after the season ended. Football utterly rotten to the core. Pr!cks.

Edited Sunday at 19:29 by BRFC4EVA

[wilsdenrover]

5 minutes ago, Mattyblue said:

No chance Man Utd won’t be picked. Doesn’t matter if it’s Arsenal away or Barnet at home, if they’re in the cup, they’re on TV.

All about the ratings as millions of pathetic armchair glory hunters will be tuning in.

I can’t find a more up to date figure but as at March ‘23 they’d had 83 of their previous 84 ties televised in the UK.

Edited Sunday at 19:30 by wilsdenrover

[Hasta]

12 minutes ago, Upside Down said:

With no replays I think that's the end of proper cup upsets. Sure, we'll get a league one side beating a championship side etc but we're not going to see none league outfits knocking out a top division side ever again.

There's no way the lower division teams can compete with the fitness, strength, quality and depth of the higher level.

Complete joke. Oh well, at least we get more turgid early round European games where Man City and Real Madrid can plod on for 90 minutes as they just go through the motions.

 

Hmm. Tamworth were literally two blocked shot in injury time away from beating Spurs this afternoon, which would have been the biggest FA Cup shock in my living memory.

Edited Sunday at 19:36 by Hasta

[superniko]

Can’t see it being a TV game. 
Not a ‘big 6 club’ and not that ‘underdog story’. 
Pretty boring draw IMO, but glad to be at home

[sharpysharps86]

Pretty happy with that draw, and a chance of an upset with it being at home, especially with Wolves having priorities elsewhere in their battle to stay in the premier league.

Doubt it'll be chosen for TV coverage though.

[SIMON GARNERS 194]

Would have rather had Liverpool or Utd at home infront of a full house.We have a chance depending on what side they put out...not a priority for us and we're not winning it!

Edited Sunday at 21:32 by SIMON GARNERS 194

[Upside Down]

47 minutes ago, Mattyblue said:

No chance Man Utd won’t be picked. Doesn’t matter if it’s Arsenal away or Barnet at home, if they’re in the cup, they’re on TV.

All about the ratings as millions of pathetic armchair glory hunters will be tuning in.

You mean chaddy's workmates?

[Exiled_Rover]

57 minutes ago, Mattyblue said:

No chance Man Utd won’t be picked. Doesn’t matter if it’s Arsenal away or Barnet at home, if they’re in the cup, they’re on TV.

All about the ratings as millions of pathetic armchair glory hunters will be tuning in.

Same with Liverpool.

[Upside Down]

43 minutes ago, Hasta said:

Hmm. Tamworth were literally two blocked shot in injury time away from beating Spurs this afternoon, which would have been the biggest FA Cup shock in my living memory.

But instead they got pumped in extra time rather than earning a replay.

With a replay on offer they smaller team can set up to be a solid defensive unit and play for the draw. Without the replay they have to try and win it in normal time as they will run out of steam come extra time as we saw with the spurs match.

It's just shit and as per usual it's all about making life easier for the biggest and richest clubs.

[magicalmortensleftpeg]

1 hour ago, Upside Down said:

But instead they got pumped in extra time rather than earning a replay.

With a replay on offer they smaller team can set up to be a solid defensive unit and play for the draw. Without the replay they have to try and win it in normal time as they will run out of steam come extra time as we saw with the spurs match.

It's just shit and as per usual it's all about making life easier for the biggest and richest clubs.

I’d argue that over two legs, the bigger club has a greater advantage than in a single leg that goes to extra time. It’s easy to say now because Spurs ultimately won, but Tamworth were 30 mins from penalties. That’s a better shot than another 90 away from home.

Certainly good arguments regarding the huge financial benefits for smaller clubs etc but don’t think scrapping replays significantly alters the odds of a big cupset.

[wilsdenrover]

Have there been any  ‘giant killings’  in replays other than Hereford (vs Newcastle)? 

[simongarnerisgod]

3 minutes ago, wilsdenrover said:

Have there been any  ‘giant killings’  in replays other than Hereford (vs Newcastle)? 

chorley beat wolves over 2 replays in 1986,remember the 3 rd game being at burnden park and chorley ran out 3-0 winners!!!they drew preston at home  in the next round and played it at ewood.incidentally it was our biggest crowd that season,just over 16000🙂

 

[Tyrone Shoelaces]

33 minutes ago, wilsdenrover said:

Have there been any  ‘giant killings’  in replays other than Hereford (vs Newcastle)? 

Err, Oxford v Rovers in 1964. We were near the top of the old First Division and flying, scoring goals for fun, they had only just been promoted to the old fourth division. When i saw the 3-1 score come in on the old BBC teletype I thought “ They’ve made a mistake there, it will be the other way around “. No it wasn’t !

Not a replay but any Rovers my age will still bear the scars !

Edited Sunday at 22:39 by Tyrone Shoelaces

[jim mk2]

3 minutes ago, Tyrone Shoelaces said:

Err, Oxford v Rovers in 1964. We were near the top of the old First Division and flying, scoring goals for fun, they had only just been promoted to the old fourth division. When i saw the 3-1 score come in on the old BBC teletype I thought “ They’ve made a mistake there, it will be the other eBay around “. No it wasn’t !

 Was that Oxford match a replay Tyrone? I remember the shock LT front page though. Still haven't recovered!

[Tyrone Shoelaces]

3 minutes ago, jim mk2 said:

 Was that Oxford match a replay Tyrone? I remember the shock LT front page though. Still haven't recovered!

No Jim. I didn’t read the small print. 
That was the beginning of our slow decline to the old divisions 2 and then 3 and a 30 year exile from the big time.

[Upside Down]

1 hour ago, magicalmortensleftpeg said:

I’d argue that over two legs, the bigger club has a greater advantage than in a single leg that goes to extra time. It’s easy to say now because Spurs ultimately won, but Tamworth were 30 mins from penalties. That’s a better shot than another 90 away from home.

Certainly good arguments regarding the huge financial benefits for smaller clubs etc but don’t think scrapping replays significantly alters the odds of a big cupset.

Earning the replay itself was a win for the smaller clubs, especially if they got to go play a premiership side away.

Now that's been taken away from them. Stealing from the poor to give to the rich as per usual.

[bluebruce]

7 hours ago, BRFC4EVA said:

Reasonable draw for us. Home game against poor prem opposition and the away team will sell out the Darwen end.

However this is not the main take home from this round. This is the first time since the disgraceful, gravy train, elitist decision to remove replays, that a really low down team has been affected vs prem opposition.

Tamworth should be looking forward to a money spinning exciting opportunity to play at Spurs new magnificent ground. Instead they're knackered, having to play an extra 30 mins and out the competition. That money could have set them up for the next 5 years.

The irony shouldn't be lost that it is against Spurs, who played that ridiculous friendly on the other side of the planet 3 days after the season ended. Football utterly rotten to the core. Pr!cks.

Worst kind of draw for me. A lesser Prem team but still with a deeper squad of quality than we can muster, so can likely rest players and still field a much stronger side. We can't rest many unless we are fine to exit the cup. Not one of the glamorous sides, so unlikely to attract a big gate, and any casual fans that go get drawn in for a dose are likely to just see us lose. If you do get one of the more glamorous sides away it can be a nice wedge.

Basically, they'll probably beat us, and we'll probably have most of our first team giving their all and wearing themselves out at the start of a congested fixture run. There's the prospect of a higher league scalp, sure, but not one of the really rewarding ones. Only get 45% of the gate on what will be a modest crowd. The sold out away end you mentioned probably means more need for policing if it happens.

I always want a home game against lower league opponents. More chance of progression, chance to rest knackered players, and the opportunity for some of the younger players to cut their teeth or fringe players to make their case. Course, we managed to balls it up in the EFL Cup against Blackpool, but that shouldn't have happened.

Totally agree on the bullshit of the elites robbing lower league teams of life-giving replays just to save themselves a match. Then they turn around and refuse to give decent solidarity down the leagues even though their money pot is creating intense downwards pressure on wages.

Edited Monday at 02:55 by bluebruce

[Eddie]

8 hours ago, Gav said:

Another nail in English football and its traditions, having no FA Cup replays is a disgrace. 

It’s all about the big clubs and money, hang yours heads in shame English FA!

It may be a break with tradition, but I love the fact that the replays have been ditched.

There's just too much football now and there's no need to add extra fixtures in. I also think it gives smaller sides a much better chance. If we were to play City, do you think we have a better chance in 30 extra minutes or if we have to start from scratch (and they may pick a stronger side second time around). 

Not only that, as a neutral, there were matches I then tuned in for this weekend that I wouldn't have under the old system as they were level and heading towards extra time. 

[rigger]

12 hours ago, Paul Mellelieu said:

Should help us fund a player loan.

When the window is shut ?